Broadway Exclusive

Early Predictions for the 2025 Tony Awards: The Best Musicals

Written by Bryan F | Jan 13, 2025 9:59:19 PM

As Broadway gets ready for another incredible year, we take a deep dive into the musicals that are already creating a buzz for the 2025 Tony Awards. From fresh new stories to beloved revivals, get ready to explore the top contenders that might just take center stage.

Here is the full list of shows that will be eligible for nomination in 2025: 

Best Musical (5 nominees)

  1. A Wonderful World

  2. Boop

  3. Buena Vista Social Club

  4. Dead Outlaw

  5. Death Becomes Her

  6. Just in Time

  7. Maybe Happy Ending

  8. Operation Mincemeat

  9. Real Women Have Curves

  10. Redwood

  11. Smash

  12. Swept Away

  13. Tammy Faye

Best Revival of a Musical (4 nominees)

  1. Floyd Collin’s

  2. Gypsy

  3. The Last Five Years

  4. Once Upon a Mattress

  5. Pirates of Penzance

  6. Sunset Boulevard

  7. Elf

The New Musicals Generating Buzz

With a diverse range of stories and musical styles, the new musicals vying for the 2025 Tony Awards are already making waves. 'A Wonderful World,' based on the life of Louis Armstrong, promises to be a standout with its rich jazz influences and compelling narrative. Meanwhile, 'Boop' brings a fresh and playful take on the iconic Betty Boop character, merging nostalgia with contemporary flair.

Other notable mentions include 'Buena Vista Social Club,' which transports audiences to the vibrant streets of Havana, and our favorite of the season so far, 'Death Becomes Her,' an adaptation of the cult classic film that combines dark comedy with dazzling musical numbers. These shows, along with others like 'Operation Mincemeat' and 'Smash,' are set to light up Broadway with their originality and artistic vision.

Revival Contenders: Old Favorites Return

The 2025 Tony Awards will also see the return of some beloved classics. 'Gypsy,' a perennial favorite, is back with a new production that promises to capture the heart and soul of its original run. 'Sunset Boulevard,' with its hauntingly beautiful score, is another revival that fans are eagerly anticipating.

In addition to these, 'The Last Five Years' and 'Once Upon a Mattress' are also making their way back to the stage, offering audiences a chance to revisit these timeless stories. 'Pirates of Penzance' and the revue 'Old Friends' add to the rich tapestry of revivals, ensuring that this year's awards will celebrate the past as much as the present.

Underdogs to Watch

Every Tony Awards season has its share of underdogs, and 2025 is no exception. 'Real Women Have Curves' is a poignant and empowering story that could surprise many with its heartfelt performances and relatable themes. 'Dead Outlaw,' with its gritty storyline and unique musical composition, is another dark horse in the race.

'Maybe Happy Ending,' an imaginative tale with a futuristic twist, and 'Redwood,' which delves into familial and cultural roots, are also worth keeping an eye on. These under-the-radar productions might just steal the spotlight from the more established names.

The Impact of New Talent

One of the most exciting aspects of the 2025 Tony Awards is the influx of new talent. Emerging composers, directors, and performers are bringing fresh perspectives and innovative approaches to the stage. This new wave of talent is not only revitalizing classic stories but also introducing groundbreaking new works.

As productions like 'A Wonderful World' and 'Boop' demonstrate, the future of Broadway is in good hands. These rising stars are poised to make a significant impact, ensuring that the 2025 Tony Awards will be a celebration of both established excellence and new beginnings.

Attending the Tony Awards

Take advantage of Broadway Exclusive's group trip packages for a weekend getaway to NYC, where you can enjoy three Broadway shows of your choosing. Additionally, we provide a special trip to NYC for the Tony Awards, giving you the opportunity to attend two shows and attend the 2025 Tony Awards at Radio City Music Hall.